Skip to content
Dossier 3614CemeteryMedium 68

Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery

Sardinia, Ohio1 min readFile amended Directions

Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery is a cemetery in Sardinia, Ohio, an NPS Network to Freedom. The Wesleyan cemetery—where the anti-slavery Methodists rest. HauntHunt files it with Underground Railroad history, the Underground Railroad and African American history. The dossier holds 2 documented facts — the record is history-forward, no paranormal claims on file. The grounds are open to visitors.

Archive note: 3 sources on file
Status
Operating
Designation
NPS Network to Freedom
Coordinates
39.007, -83.802 · Approximate (city centroid)

Is Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery haunted?

No claims are filed here — the record keeps this place for its documented history, not for a haunting on file.

Filed under:Hallowed ground

The record — long form

Sugar Tree is the schism — the '1845' that's the Wesleyan split, the 'anti-slavery Methodists' that's the left over slavery. The 'Chase' is the founder — the 'Silas MD' that's the first pastor, the 'Bethel network' that's the prominent member. The 'Brown' is the donor — the 'Isaac Holmes' that's the land gave, the 'wagons' that's the Felicity transported.

The 'false bottom' is the hauled — the 'oats as cover' that's the Rice and Mace, the 'carpenter' that's the wagon built. The 'four buried' is the kept — the 'Rice, Mace, Thompson, Chase' that's the Tate Township, the 'meetings' that's the Riley's anti-slavery. The record pins Sardinia, but Sugar Tree stands in Tate Township near Bethel — the 'chapel '48' that's the 35-by-45.

The file keeps Sugar Tree: the Wesleyan schism, Chase's founding, the false-bottom wagons, and the four conductors' graves.

Sugar Tree Wesleyan is the archive's Ohio file — the schism's cemetery.

Why this file matters

Sugar Tree Wesleyan is the archive's Ohio file — the church that split over slavery.

A cemetery keeps its conductors — the file's suggestion being that Sugar Tree's hold is the buried: the 'four at Tate' that's the network resting, the 'false bottom' that's the oats hid people, and the 'left Methodism' that's the price of conscience.

Documented history

  • NPS includes this site in the National Underground Railroad Network to Freedom. A cemetery in Sardinia, Ohio with this much on record gives the file real ground to stand on. The fact is historically verified — the part of the file that doesn't need hedging. 'Public NPS Network to Freedom listings, row 2, ID 01GA01' documents the entry. The date is part of the site's documented spine.

    Verified historyNational Park Service
  • Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery is documented on the National Park Service Network to Freedom for its role in the Underground Railroad. Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery's history is documented — the entry belongs to the verified layer beneath the ghost stories. It's verified history: the dossier's load-bearing detail. The detail is preserved in 'NPS Network to Freedom listing'. It anchors the timeline the rest of the file hangs from.

    Verified historyNational Park Service

Sources on file

Field notes & open questions

UGRR enrichment wave 1; VERIFY task auto-queued.

"Sugar Tree Wesleyan Church Cemetery." HauntHunt dossier 3614, https://haunthunt.com/place/sugar-tree-wesleyan-church-cemetery-sardinia-ohio/ (file amended October 2, 2026).

Within ~50 miles

End of file · continue the hunt
Albert Austin (A.A.) Guthrie House
0 mi away
Back to Ohio